Baking snapshot with autoid

[dereuromark]

Description

When baking

bin/cake bake migration_snapshot Init

The result contains already

public bool $autoId = false;

But there is a specific flag for it, so I would assume it wouldnt do that for us out of the box.
Otherwise we need the opposite flag enable-autoid:

--disable-autoid      Disable phinx behavior of automatically adding an
                      id field.

Bake Version

3.0.4

PHP Version

PHP 8.2

[ndm2]

That is the intended behavior when there are primary keys that conflict with the Migrations.unsigned_primary_keys config, it's the continuation of the old behavior of unsigned primary keys causing the option to be generated.

Maybe it's possible to drop this behavior, and treat incompatible primary keys as "special primary keys" just like for example composite primary keys, for which table() call options are generated accordingly, but I'm not sure, with migrations there's always 5 implications lurking around the corner, just waiting to smash your kneecaps.

[dereuromark]

Could we switch the config to --enable-autoid and then force the unsigned keys where needed or alike?
Maybe to be safe another option --force-unsigned on top here if needed?

[ndm2]

I'm not sure, maybe. Figuring out the technical implications and possible unwanted side effects will take some time.

[dereuromark]

Well, the migrations before were with autoid, and I would expect the merged one to be the same.
If we need to force this somehow, that sounds reasable to me.

[github-actions]

This issue is stale because it has been open for 120 days with no activity. Remove the stale label or comment or this will be closed in 15 days