-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 17
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Multi-mission sensitive to model size and variable splitting #102
Comments
@1ozturkbe @bqpd I noticed some pretty interesting things. First off, compare these two commits 3a4ee22 (doesn't work) 51009fd .... (works) @bqpd correct me if I'm wrong but I think this indicates there's a bug in how GPkit is handling these vector variables? Also, I think we discovered Mosek can't solve the really big problems because this commit works 51009fd while this one doesn't 3f256df. The only difference should be the size of the problem. |
@mayork I do think that there were some potentially problematic constraints, and I pushed some changes to the branch multiFix in an effort to get multimission working. I would think that these constraints would have definitely caused primal infeasibility. |
@1ozturkbe multi-mission does work, but not for large Nmission vals |
@mayork that does look like a bug, I'll take a look. As for the size issue...I sure hope it's not a max-number-of-variables thing. :-/ I feel like MOSEK would exit with a memory error if it were? |
@mayork does it fail on the first solve with the additional mission? If so, could you upload the working/not-working mskexpopt problem statement files so I could send them to MOSEK? |
@bqpd doesn't fail on the first solve. remind me again how to generate the mskexpopt? |
I think it's |
3f256df also works for me...on convexengineering/gpkit@585d8bf and presumably the two commits before it, since they just change documentation/tests |
There are no size limits in MOSEK and it should never crash. It may not solve your problem due to numerical issues though. If you think MOSEK has a bug you want us to look at, then please report it to https://www.mosek.com/support/ Just include information so it easy for us to reproduce the issue. |
Issue to discuss growing pains in the multi-mission analysis
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: