-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 3.2k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Update "Size and anchors" to reflect Godot 4.3 terminology #10216
Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Thank you for contributing by updating this page! There are some changes that need to be made, though:
- You'll need to update the images to preserve their original meaning, and change the format to WebP.
- There are also a few style changes to make.
The content looks fine, as it's mostly unchanged other than the 3.x->4.x terminology changes.
(Reviewed for style guidelines, but did not deeply review for correctness in 4.x. I believe that anchor offsets still function like margins did, but this will need a review from someone more familiar with UI as well.)
I believe this might close #9950. |
Thank you for the thorough and respectful comments and suggestions. I will go through them tomorrow when I have time. I don't know why I didn't realize that the images were baked in collages whilst editing, a bit of a oversight. I'll take and edit new screenshots tomorrow as well :) |
If you are also taking new screenshots of the control examples, please use |
Alright, will do. Thank you for the tip! :) |
When I reviewed, I didn't notice this is a duplicate of #10005 and #8855 (all of which try to address #5121). This PR makes the most minimal changes, only swapping terminiology and updating the screenshots. I would tentatively suggest bringing this PR to a mergable state, which would make this page at least not obviously incorrect. Then we can consider salvaging some of the other two PRs to rewrite the page more completely. |
Should hopefully be up to spec now. Let me know if there's anything else I need to do. |
I also removed the old images now. I did a search with Visual Studio Code, and it scored no hits on any of the files removed. |
Hopefully addressed the wordy paragraph I introduced in the original pull request now, too. |
I have now replaced the transparent images with ones including a backdrop of |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Looks good to me, thanks for making all the changes! This will be reviewed by at least one other reviewer, then it should be good to merge.
Note that at some point you should squash all the commits, as described here. We prefer one commit per PR (though it's less strict in the docs repo). You can either do so now, or after all reviews are done.
For other reviewers: as noted in #10216 (comment) (and the older PRs linked), this page still needs a larger rewrite at some point. This PR makes the page factually correct, but the page is still not really the right tutorial for using anchors and offsets in Godot 4. At some point I'll try to salvage the other two older PRs into a full rewrite.
Thank you :) The larger rewrite does sound like a good idea. I'll look into squashing in a bit. I usually don't squash since I prefer the granularity, but I definetely understand why you'd want a cleaner commit history in such a large project. |
I'm not sure if this ended up being correct... It says " I put Sorry for my naivety. I greatly appreciate your patience with me. Whilst I am studying computer science, they haven't been very rigorous with git past the very basics and cherrypicked examples - so I am very much out of my depth here. I have a backup of my repo in case I need to redo this. My process went like this:
git rebase -i eee29a2 # The commit before my first one This opened Neovim (my assigned editor for git), whereby I edited every commit line that was mine and not the initial commit to be git push --force Yes, I will be the junior dev who invetably ends up nuking the company repo on my first day 😅 |
This comment was marked as resolved.
This comment was marked as resolved.
1f4c0af
to
c2e697c
Compare
Changed relevant occurences of margin with "anchor offset" or "offset". Also reworded paragraph about aspect ratios, as it included information that may not necessarily be correct. Also replaced images with newer versions.
I think it might be correct now. It turned out that my I had to execute git remote add upstream [email protected]:godotengine/godot-docs.git
git pull --rebase upstream master # Probably not necessary
git rebase -i upstream/master # As per the guide At which point I was only presented with my own commits instead of everything else, like intended. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Thanks! Congratulations for your first merged pull request 🎉
Thank you :) |
…ne#10216) Changed relevant occurences of margin with "anchor offset" or "offset". Also reworded paragraph about aspect ratios, as it included information that may not necessarily be correct. Also replaced images with newer versions.
Changed relevant occurences of margin with "anchor offset" or "offset". Also reworded paragraph about aspect ratios, as it included information that may not necessarily be correct. Also replaced images with newer versions.
Cherrypicked to 4.3 in #10346. |
It included terms like "margin" which seem to have been replaced by "Anchor Offsets".
I also replaced the relevant screenshots, but chose not to delete the old ones as I didn't want to accidentally break another article.
This is my second ever contribution to any open source project, so please do have patience with me if I got something wrong. I'll try my best to fix it.