You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
<gitCommitIdLength>integer</gitCommitIdLength> <!-- between [8,40] -->
In Github all short commit IDs usually have 7 digits length, like in this project: c14645a.
If the Git commit ID from jgitver is used to create docker containers, for example, it is useful to have their tag correspond to a commit ID on Github. This is not possible, if the lower bound for the gitCommitIdLength is 8 instead of 7.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
concerning you're feedback: the sha1 that you are pointing on 7 chars c14645a is exactly the same if you use 8 characters c14645a1 or even 40 c14645a1900b47ac92c516319a987e6173e93006 so really I see no concern in using 7 or 8 characters to denote a commit id until it uniquely identifies a commit. And you will admit that with 8 characters you have less chances to collide than with 7.
then as you have seen in jgitver the short id is set to 8 characters (length hardcoded) here.
you're asking for 7 but based on git documentation the number of characters should be upper than 4 and controlled by the config option core.abbrev with a default value computed depending on the repository hashes (introduced in git 2.11.0).
On other parts of the git documentation I found mention of a default value to 7 which was a default prior to git-2.11.0.
I think that if an evolution is done, prviding for example a new Metadatas.GIT_SHA1_SHORT for example, it will have to take into account as much as possible core.abbrev config.
I have reported the enhancement request on jgitver itself jgitver/jgitver#142.
Issue
version: 1.9.0
usage context: any
Problem description:
Docs for settings say:
In Github all short commit IDs usually have
7
digits length, like in this project: c14645a.If the Git commit ID from jgitver is used to create docker containers, for example, it is useful to have their tag correspond to a commit ID on Github. This is not possible, if the lower bound for the
gitCommitIdLength
is 8 instead of 7.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: