Commit
This commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository.
[RFC] Rust: A fallible from_kernel_errno with Result<Error> return
Currently, from_kernel_errno is an infallible function acting as a constructor for Error. In order to achieve its type invariant, We add a check in it which will prompt a warning and return Error::EINVL when errno given is invalid. While this approach ensures type invariant, it brings great ambiguities. When Error::EINVL is returned, the caller has no way to recognize whether it is a valid errno coming from the kernel or an error issued by the check. This tricky behavior may confuse developers and introduce subtle bugs. Since Error will be used in all respects of the kernel, It's definitely not a sound solution. This RFC proposes that we make from_kernel_errno return a Result<Error>. Thus, we have an explicit, clear, and fallible version of from_kernel_errno by which callers are able to know what really happened behind the scene. And it also provides certain flexibility. We pass the power to callers, they can decide how to deal with invalid `errno` case by case.
- Loading branch information