-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 4
Commit
This commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository.
Make sure negative points are considered as well
- Loading branch information
1 parent
39cefdf
commit 86af90e
Showing
1 changed file
with
13 additions
and
13 deletions.
There are no files selected for viewing
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change |
---|---|---|
@@ -1,26 +1,26 @@ | ||
\subsection*{Exercise 16 (Cecilia)} | ||
For all point $ p $ in $ E $ | ||
\begin{eqnarray*} | ||
p^2 < 3 \\ | ||
\implies p^2 < 4 \\ | ||
\implies p < 2 \\ | ||
\implies |0 - p| < 2 \\ | ||
\implies d(0, p) < 2 | ||
\end{eqnarray*} | ||
\begin{flalign*} | ||
p^2 &< 3 \\ | ||
p^2 &< 4 \\ | ||
|p| &< 2 \\ | ||
|0 - p| &< 2 \\ | ||
d(0, p) &< 2 | ||
\end{flalign*} | ||
Therefore $ E $ is bounded. | ||
|
||
if $ a \in \mathbb{Q} $ and $ a^2 < 2 $, let $ d = \sqrt{2} - a $, then the neighborhood $ N_d(a) $ does not intersect $ E $, therefore $ a $ is not a limit point of $ E $. | ||
if $ a \in \mathbb{Q} $ and $ a^2 < 2 $, let $ d = \min(|a - \sqrt{2}|, |a + \sqrt{2}|) $, then the neighborhood $ N_d(a) $ does not intersect $ E $, therefore $ a $ is not a limit point of $ E $. | ||
|
||
Similarly, if $ b \in \mathbb{Q} $ and $ b^2 > 2 $, let $ d = b - \sqrt{3} $, then the neighborhood $ N_d(b) $ does not intersect $ E $, therefore $ b $ is not a limit point of $ E $. | ||
Similarly, if $ b \in \mathbb{Q} $ and $ b^2 > 3 $, let $ d = \min(|b - \sqrt{3}|,|b + \sqrt{3}|) $, then the neighborhood $ N_d(b) $ does not intersect $ E $, therefore $ b $ is not a limit point of $ E $. | ||
|
||
Therefore $ E^c $ does not contain any limit point of $ E $, and so $ E $ contains all its limit points and is closed. | ||
|
||
Consider the open cover $ (0, p) $ for all rational $ p $ such that $ 0 < p^2 < 3 $. | ||
Consider the open cover $ (-p, p) $ for all rational $ p $ such that $ 0 < p < \sqrt{3} $. | ||
|
||
The open cover does cover $ E $ because for all $ x \in E $, there exists a rational number $ p $ such that $ x < p < \sqrt{3} $ by theorem 1.20b, and so $ x \in (0, p) $. | ||
The open cover does cover $ E $ because for all $ x \in E $, there exists a rational number $ p $ such that $ |x| < p < \sqrt{3} $ by theorem 1.20b, and so $ x \in (-p, p) $. | ||
|
||
Any finite subcover of the open cover will have a maximum rational number $ p $ such that $ p^2 < 3 $, and by theorem 1.20b again, there exists a rational number $ q $ such that $ p < q < \sqrt{3} $, and so $ q \notin (0, p) $, and so the finite subcover does not cover $ E $. | ||
Any finite subcover of the open cover will have a maximum rational number $ p $ such that $ p^2 < 3 $, and by theorem 1.20b again, there exists a rational number $ q $ such that $ p < q < \sqrt{3} $, and so $ q \notin (-p, p) $, and so the finite subcover does not cover $ E $. | ||
|
||
Therefore $ E $ is not compact. | ||
|
||
For any $ p \in E $, the neighborhood $ N_{min(p-\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}-p)}(p) $ does not intersect $ E^c $, and so $ p $ is an interior point of $ E $, which means $ E $ is open. | ||
For any $ p \in E $, the neighborhood $ N_{\min(|p-\sqrt{2}|, |p+\sqrt{2}|, |p-\sqrt{3}|, |p+\sqrt{3}|}(p) $ does not intersect $ E^c $, and so $ p $ is an interior point of $ E $, which means $ E $ is open. |