Refactor: Remove side effects from data provider #7478
Conversation
|
@pulsovi thanks for the contribution! It appears our older automated tests are failing due to this change probably due to implementation update. https://github.com/impress-org/givewp/actions/runs/10254681539/job/29133510148?pr=7478 |
pulsovi
force-pushed
the
fix/test/test-misc-functions
branch
from
8e837fc
to
53407f1
Compare
- Eliminated side effects in test_give_meta_helpers data provider - Ensures consistent test environment regardless of --filter usage This change prevents unexpected failures when running specific tests with PHPUnit's --filter option.
double declaration of `add_filter('..._post_meta')` breaks the return
value. See test: Tests_MISC_Functions::test_give_meta_helpers
MyIsam engine does not support transactions
pulsovi
force-pushed
the
fix/test/test-misc-functions
branch
from
53407f1
to
30a6faf
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@pulsovi it looks like this PR has expanded from fixing our legacy test suite side effects to modifying code in production. Please understand this introduces risk to this PR and is something we have to be very careful about as it could impact our customers.
What exactly are you hoping to solve it here?
| @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ public function run() { | |||
| created_at DATETIME NOT NULL, | |||
| updated_at DATETIME NOT NULL, | |||
| PRIMARY KEY (id) | |||
| ) $charset"; | |||
| ) $charset ENGINE=InnoDB;"; | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
What's the purpose of adding this?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
On my machine where the default engine is MyISAM, many of the tests crash because of their interactions.
Indeed, the teardown cleanup function of legacy tests uses SQL transactions with ROLLBACK to undo any modification of the DB by the test.
But MyISAM does not manage transactions...
This is why I suggest explicit use of the InnoDB engine.
| 'donors_db' => give()->get(Give_DB_Donors::class), | ||
| 'donor_meta_db' => give()->get(Give_DB_Donor_Meta::class), | ||
| 'comment_db' => give()->get(Give_DB_Comments::class), | ||
| 'comment_db_meta' => give()->get(Give_DB_Comment_Meta::class), | ||
| 'give_session' => give()->get(Give_DB_Sessions::class), | ||
| 'formmeta_db' => give()->get(Give_DB_Form_Meta::class), | ||
| 'sequential_db' => give()->get(Give_DB_Sequential_Ordering::class), | ||
| 'donation_meta' => give()->get(Give_DB_Payment_Meta::class), |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
What's happening here?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
All of these classes are extensions of Give_DB_Meta.
However, this class, during its instantiation, will override all post modification methods via hooks such as:
if (in_array('delete_post_metadata', $this->supports)) {
add_filter('delete_post_metadata', [$this, '__delete_meta'], 0, 5);
}This will trigger a bugged behavior if one of these classes is instantiated more than once.
In the specific case of deletion, the return value indicates the number of rows deleted from the database.
But if the hook is called by several instances of the class, this is what will happen:
- The first hook will do the deletion work and return the number of rows deleted
- The second hook will look for lines to delete, find none (they were all deleted by the first hook) and therefore return the value
0 - The hook ends by systematically returning
0, the return value is wrong.
For this reason, I made the minimum possible modifications to approach singleton pattern behavior.
This is the code you present here.
|
@jonwaldstein Hi, I'm not very familiar with the PR treatment process. What should I do here next? |
|
This PR is stale because it has been open 45 days with no activity. Stale PRs will NOT be automatically closed. |
Issue
Tests_MISC_Functions->test_give_meta_helpers's data provider had side effects, which caused unexpected failures when using the --filter option of PHPUnit.Solution
Impact
This change improves test reliability and isolation, allowing more predictable execution, especially when using --filter.
Good practice
Data providers should never have side effects to guarantee the consistency and independence of the tests.