You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
⏱️ Estimated effort to review: 2 🔵🔵⚪⚪⚪
🧪 No relevant tests
🔒 No security concerns identified
⚡ Recommended focus areas for review
Error Handling The workflow has continue-on-error set for critical steps like installing SST and retrieving app URL. This could mask important failures.
Dependency Change The removal of the 'needs: [embed]' dependency could cause race conditions if both jobs run in parallel.
Why: Removing continue-on-error from critical steps is crucial as it prevents masking of important failures that could affect the deployment process. This change ensures proper error reporting and workflow integrity.
8
Best practice
Add error handling and logging for secret configuration commands to improve debugging and reliability
Add error handling for the sst secret commands using conditional execution (&&) to ensure all secrets are set correctly before proceeding with deployment.
-npm run sst secret set PartnerId ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_PARTNER_ID }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set CallbackUrl ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_CALLBACK_URL }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set SmileIdApiKey ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_API_KEY }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set SmileIdEnvironment ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_ENVIRONMENT }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}+if ! npm run sst secret set PartnerId ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_PARTNER_ID }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}; then+ echo "Failed to set PartnerId secret" && exit 1+fi &&+if ! npm run sst secret set CallbackUrl ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_CALLBACK_URL }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}; then+ echo "Failed to set CallbackUrl secret" && exit 1+fi &&+if ! npm run sst secret set SmileIdApiKey ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_API_KEY }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}; then+ echo "Failed to set SmileIdApiKey secret" && exit 1+fi &&+if ! npm run sst secret set SmileIdEnvironment ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_ENVIRONMENT }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}; then+ echo "Failed to set SmileIdEnvironment secret" && exit 1+fi
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7
Why: The suggestion adds robust error handling and logging for secret configuration, which would help identify and debug deployment issues more effectively. This is important for maintaining deployment reliability.
7
Add error handling for network operations to improve workflow reliability
Add error handling to the curl command by checking its exit status and providing a fallback or error message if the download fails.
Why: Adding explicit error handling for the curl command is important for workflow reliability, as it ensures failures are caught and reported properly rather than potentially being silently ignored.
7
Add error handling for command execution to ensure proper workflow failure reporting
Add error handling for the npm run sst remove command to ensure the workflow fails appropriately if the removal fails.
-npm run sst remove -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SS_STAGE }}+npm run sst remove -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SS_STAGE }} || { echo "Failed to remove SST app"; exit 1; }
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7
Why: Adding error handling for the SST removal command is valuable as it ensures the workflow will explicitly fail if the cleanup operation fails, preventing potential resource leaks or incomplete cleanups.
Enhance security by verifying the integrity of downloaded installation scripts
Consider pinning the curl installation script to a specific hash to prevent potential supply chain attacks. This ensures the downloaded script hasn't been tampered with.
Why: Adding hash verification for downloaded scripts is a critical security practice that helps prevent supply chain attacks and ensures script integrity.
9
Possible issue
Remove error suppression from critical workflow steps to ensure proper error handling
Remove continue-on-error from critical steps like retrieving app URL since failures should stop the workflow.
Why: Removing continue-on-error from the URL retrieval step is critical as this is an essential operation, and its failure should stop the workflow to prevent sharing invalid preview URLs.
8
Best practice
Add error handling to ensure secret configuration commands complete successfully
Add error handling and status checks after each secret setting command to ensure all secrets are properly configured before deployment.
-npm run sst secret set PartnerId ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_PARTNER_ID }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set CallbackUrl ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_CALLBACK_URL }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set SmileIdApiKey ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_API_KEY }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set SmileIdEnvironment ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_ENVIRONMENT }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}+npm run sst secret set PartnerId ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_PARTNER_ID }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1+npm run sst secret set CallbackUrl ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_CALLBACK_URL }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1+npm run sst secret set SmileIdApiKey ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_API_KEY }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1+npm run sst secret set SmileIdEnvironment ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_ENVIRONMENT }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7
Why: Adding explicit error handling with || exit 1 ensures the workflow fails immediately if any secret configuration fails, preventing deployment with incomplete configuration.
7
Add explicit error handling to prevent silent failures in CI/CD pipeline commands
Add error handling to ensure the sst remove command executes successfully, preventing silent failures in the workflow.
-npm run sst remove -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SS_STAGE }}+npm run sst remove -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SS_STAGE }} || exit 1
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7
Why: Explicit error handling with exit codes is important for CI/CD reliability, ensuring pipeline failures are properly caught and reported rather than silently continuing.
Why: The suggestion addresses a critical security concern by adding integrity verification for downloaded scripts, which helps prevent supply chain attacks and ensures the authenticity of the installer script before execution.
9
Possible issue
Remove error suppression from critical workflow steps to ensure failures are properly detected
Remove continue-on-error from critical steps like retrieving the app URL since this could mask important failures.
Why: Removing continue-on-error from critical steps like URL retrieval is important for detecting deployment issues, as masking these failures could lead to incomplete or failed deployments going unnoticed.
8
Best practice
Add error handling to fail the workflow if any secret configuration fails
Add error handling and status checks after each secret setting command to ensure all secrets are properly configured before deployment.
-npm run sst secret set PartnerId ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_PARTNER_ID }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set CallbackUrl ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_CALLBACK_URL }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set SmileIdApiKey ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_API_KEY }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} &&-npm run sst secret set SmileIdEnvironment ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_ENVIRONMENT }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }}+npm run sst secret set PartnerId ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_PARTNER_ID }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1+npm run sst secret set CallbackUrl ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_CALLBACK_URL }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1+npm run sst secret set SmileIdApiKey ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_API_KEY }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1+npm run sst secret set SmileIdEnvironment ${{ secrets.PREVIEW_SMILEID_ENVIRONMENT }} -- --stage ${{ steps.get_branch_name.outputs.SST_STAGE }} || exit 1
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7
Why: The suggestion improves reliability by ensuring the workflow fails immediately if any secret configuration fails, rather than potentially continuing with missing secrets.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Update sst version
Fix smart-camera-web and web embed preview url not shared as comment