Meeting 2019 12 16

AGENDA

1. Review of the actions defined during the previous meeting Actions:

   • From the previous meeting:
     • ACTION: Piotr will update the table with Database as 'Draft
     • ACTION: Piotr will add numbers to the 'core' specifications
     • ACTION: Piotr Will create an issue to define a mission statement (ultimate goal) of the RFCs. Igor proposed to define also a PR template.
     • ACTION: Piotr will create a specific branch for Request-Reply RFC and will gover the PRs.
   • Older:
     • (2019-11-18): ACTION: Vincent: to review RFC-14 (Logging service) as well.
     • (2019-11-18): ACTION: All working on RFCs: check YAML header in your PR if editor is specified
     • ACTION: Piotr: make a report for the Board based on the work started by Vincent.
     • Sergi will review Michals's PR.
     • ACTION: Find an editor for RFC-13 (will be needed upon RFC-12 is done).
     • ACTION: Andy suggested to rename the file of each RFC by there number. Piotr will create an issue and PR with a proposition to be discussed on GitHub.

2. Status of the existing RFC list

   • The current goal:

     • Property RFC in draft.

   • update on current WIP

     • Properties
     • Attributes
     • Publisher-Subscriber protocol
     • Publisher-Subscriber protocol implementation with ZMQ
     • Device server
     • Tango Controls
     • Database
     • Logging Service
     • Data types

   • new RFC-s proposition

3. AoB:

4. Next meeting:

Minutes

Participants: Andrew Goetz, Reynald Bourtembourg (ESRF), Piotr Goryl (S2Innovation), David Erb, Vincent Hardion (MAX-IV), Igor Khokhriakov (IK), Lorenzo Pivetta(Elettra)

1. Review of the actions defined during the previous meeting Actions:

   • From the previous meeting:

     • (2019-12-02) ACTION: Piotr will update the table with Database as 'Draft
     • (2019-12-02) ACTION: Piotr will add numbers to the 'core' specifications
     • (2019-12-02) ACTION: Piotr Will create an issue to define a mission statement (ultimate goal) of the RFCs. Igor proposed to define also a PR template.
     • (2019-12-02) ACTION: Piotr will create a specific branch for Request-Reply RFC and will gover the PRs.

   • Older:

     • (2019-11-18): ACTION: Vincent: to review RFC-14 (Logging service) as well.
     • (2019-11-18): ACTION: All working on RFCs: check YAML header in your PR if editor is specified
     • ACTION: Piotr: make a report for the Board based on the work started by Vincent.
     • Sergi will review Michals's PR.
     • ACTION: Andy suggested to rename the file of each RFC by there number. Piotr will create an issue and PR with a proposition to be discussed on GitHub. Two proposition are sent as PRs.
       • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Piotr will send a message to all to ask for comments/voting, to be able to take a decision in January.

2. Status of the existing RFC list

   • The current goal:

     • Property RFC in draft.

   • update on current WIP

     • Properties - Discussion on where to put text representation of properties values. The conclusion is to left it for maybe later as it is more implementation details.
       • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Reynald will ask Gwen for review
     • Attributes - no news
     • Publisher-Subscriber protocol - no news
     • Publisher-Subscriber protocol implementation with ZMQ - no news
     • Device server - no news
     • Tango Controls - Andy is sending a PR :-). All are welcome to review.
     • Logging Service - no news.
     • Data types - Missing types are added. Reviewed types naming and issue with element orders implied by the ABNF.
       • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Piotr will left only DevCamelCase names. Then ask Gwen for editor review.
     • Request-Reply - the branch is already created.
       • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Piotr will add templated to it.

   • new RFC-s proposition - no new propositions

3. AoB:

   • It would be good to have another 'Write the RFC' workshop.
     • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Piotr will create and send a doodle for finding time for the 2nd WtR workshop.

4. Next meeting: 13.01.2020, All the best for Christmas and the New Year!