Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Apr 7, 2022. It is now read-only.

Meeting 2020 01 27

Jump to bottom
Michal Liszcz edited this page Jan 27, 2020 · 3 revisions

AGENDA

  1. Review of the actions defined during the previous meeting Actions:

    • From the previous meeting:
    • Older:
      • (2019-11-18): ACTION: Vincent: to review RFC-14 (Logging service) as well.
      • (2019-11-18): ACTION: All working on RFCs: check YAML header in your PR if editor is specified
      • Sergi will review Michals's PR.
        • (2020-01-13): A reminder was sent on slack.
      • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Piotr will send a message about proposed new file naming schemas asking for comments/voting, to be able to take a decision in January.
        • (2020-01-13): Reynald suggested to include this information also in the invitation for the next RFC team meeting so that votes from more people can be collected and decision can be made during the next meeting.

  2. Status of the existing RFC list

    • The current goal:

      • Data Types RFC in draft.

    • update on current WIP

      • RFC-4 Attributes
      • RFC-12 Publisher-Subscriber protocol
      • RFC-13 Publisher-Subscriber protocol implementation with ZMQ
      • RFC-8 Device server
      • RFC-1 Tango Controls
      • RFC-14 Logging Service
      • RFC-9 Data types
      • RFC-10 Request-Reply
      • RFC-7 Pipe
      • RFC-15 Dynamic Attribute and Command

    • new RFC-s proposition

      • API_ErrorReasons / Tango Const

  3. AoB:

    • File naming
    • Report from WtRFC remote workshop

  4. Next meeting:

MINUTES

Participants: Sergi Blanch-Torné (ALBA), Vincent Hardion (MAX-IV), Michal Liszcz (S2Innovation)

  1. Review of the actions defined during the previous meeting Actions:

    • From the previous meeting:
    • Older:
      • (2019-11-18): ACTION: Vincent: to review RFC-14 (Logging service) as well.
      • Sergi will review Michals's PR.
        • (2020-01-13): A reminder was sent on slack.
        • (2020-01-27): Done
      • (2019-12-16) ACTION: Piotr will send a message about proposed new file naming schemas asking for comments/voting, to be able to take a decision in January.
        • (2020-01-13): Reynald suggested to include this information also in the invitation for the next RFC team meeting so that votes from more people can be collected and decision can be made during the next meeting.

  2. Status of the existing RFC list

    • The current goal:

      • Data Types RFC in draft.

    • update on current WIP

      • RFC-4 Attributes
        • (2020-01-27) PR with Attribute Properties table merged
      • RFC-12 Publisher-Subscriber protocol
      • RFC-13 Publisher-Subscriber protocol implementation with ZMQ
        • (2020-01-27) Some input is needed from Vincent in the PR discussion
      • RFC-8 Device server
        • (2020-01-27) Lorenzo opened a new PR (#79) which obsoletes the old one (#58). Vincent will review this new PR.
      • RFC-1 Tango Controls
      • RFC-14 Logging Service
        • (2020-01-27) ACTION: Sergi to review RFC-14 as an editor.
        • Still there are some conflicts that must be resolved before merge.
      • RFC-9 Data types
        • (2020-01-27): Piotr: Applying Gwen and Rynald comments to RFC-9 (it is almost finished)
      • RFC-10 Request-Reply
        • (2020-01-27): Piotr: Working on RFC-10 template (PR created)
        • PR with bullet points has been created (#67) so that multiple contributors can work on different parts of this RFC.
          • ACTION: Michal to check with Piotr why this PR is WIP and what is the current status.
      • RFC-7 Pipe
        • (2020-01-27): Recently reviewed by Reynald. Needs input from Olga.
      • RFC-15 Dynamic Attribute and Command
        • (2020-01-27): Recently reviewed by Reynald. Needs input from Olga.

    • new RFC-s proposition

      • API_ErrorReasons / Tango Const
        • Error codes could go to RFC-9 as well as to a dedicated RFC.
        • Vincent suggested to put a recommendation what shall be included in DevError.
        • Vincent and Sergi will read the discussion in RFC-9 to have better understanding for the need of this new RFC.
        • Discussion will continue on the next meeting when Piotr will be availabe.

  3. AoB:

    • File naming
      • "Naming the files according to the rfc 'shortname'" (#72) is preferable (has most of the votes)
      • Vincent has some coments regarding case/capitalization.
      • Further discussion will take place in PR's comments.
    • Report from WtRFC remote workshop
      • No one from the meeting participants has attended the workshop.
    • RFC Mission Statement (#67)
      • Vincent suggested to combine Piotr's and David's comments and put the mission statement on the main README page.
      • ACTION: Michal to ask Piotr about status of this issue.

  4. Next meeting: 10.02.2020 15.00 CET

Clone this wiki locally